Divisão de Observação da Terra e Geoinformática

Ferramentas do usuário

Ferramentas do site

Visitou:
geopro:pedro:mobility:revisao-jasss

Diferenças

Aqui você vê as diferenças entre duas revisões dessa página.

Link para esta página de comparações

Próxima revisão		Revisão anterior
geopro:pedro:mobility:revisao-jasss [2008/07/03 20:33] – created pedrogeopro:pedro:mobility:revisao-jasss [2008/07/03 20:36] (atual) – pedro
Linha 15: Linha 15:
  
  
 +===== Referee 1: =====
  
- 
-___________________________________________________________________________ 
- 
-Referee 1: 
  
 The article presents an interesting model to study the dynamics of  The article presents an interesting model to study the dynamics of 
Linha 37: Linha 34:
  
 There are two negative aspects to emphasize:   There are two negative aspects to emphasize:  
- There is not any justification for the hypothesis of the model.  +There is not any justification for the hypothesis of the model.  
- About which class of individuals or content are the authors thinking?   +About which class of individuals or content are the authors thinking?   
- Really I don't know any that can be approximated by the kind of agent and game       +Really I don't know any that can be approximated by the kind of agent and game       
- presented here. +presented here. 
  
- No spatial or mobility information is obtained from the results of the    +No spatial or mobility information is obtained from the results of the    
- model. When I read the title 'Games on Cellular Spaces: How Mobility Affects  +model. When I read the title 'Games on Cellular Spaces: How Mobility Affects  
- Equilibrium', thought to find information as the agents are grouped or   +Equilibrium', thought to find information as the agents are grouped or   
- repelled spatially,  or perhaps somewhat about the mean path. The only   +repelled spatially,  or perhaps somewhat about the mean path. The only   
- information is the number of movements carried out for each category of   +information is the number of movements carried out for each category of   
- player. +player. 
  
 The first criticism can be met by adding in the introduction section the ideas  The first criticism can be met by adding in the introduction section the ideas 
 that guided the author to propose this type of dynamics. If it is possible,  that guided the author to propose this type of dynamics. If it is possible, 
 justify what type of society or behaviour tries to shape with this play.  justify what type of society or behaviour tries to shape with this play. 
-   
  
 The second can be part of a future work; I believe that the cellular space  The second can be part of a future work; I believe that the cellular space 
Linha 85: Linha 81:
  
  
-*******  If the article describes a simulation model, is there enough detail +**  If the article describes a simulation model, is there enough detail 
 provided for the relevant output from the model to be replicated by a reader  provided for the relevant output from the model to be replicated by a reader 
 (the description might be in the form of an algorithm, pseudo-code, or access  (the description might be in the form of an algorithm, pseudo-code, or access 
-to the simulation program itself)? +to the simulation program itself)? **
  
 The authors give no detail of how the simulation is implemented, neither on  The authors give no detail of how the simulation is implemented, neither on 
Linha 94: Linha 90:
  
  
-*******  Has the author sufficiently taken advantage of the opportunities +**  Has the author sufficiently taken advantage of the opportunities 
 available through electronic publication (e.g. access to program code or data;  available through electronic publication (e.g. access to program code or data; 
 colour illustrations; animations)?  If not, have you any suggestions that  colour illustrations; animations)?  If not, have you any suggestions that 
-could be forwarded to the author? +could be forwarded to the author? **
  
 The author only uses the colour illustrations. The author only uses the colour illustrations.
-___________________________________________________________________________ 
  
-Referee 2:+ 
 +===== Referee 2: ===== 
  
 The objectives are clear and the model, as well as the procedure and the  The objectives are clear and the model, as well as the procedure and the 
Linha 117: Linha 114:
  
  
-*******   If the article describes a simulation model, is there enough detail +**   If the article describes a simulation model, is there enough detail 
 provided for the relevant output from the model to be replicated by a reader  provided for the relevant output from the model to be replicated by a reader 
 (the description might be in the form of an algorithm, pseudo-code, or access  (the description might be in the form of an algorithm, pseudo-code, or access 
-to the simulation program itself)? +to the simulation program itself)? **
  
 The model was clearly explained and the author/s provides a verbose  The model was clearly explained and the author/s provides a verbose 
Linha 129: Linha 126:
  
  
-*******   Has the author sufficiently taken advantage of the opportunities +**   Has the author sufficiently taken advantage of the opportunities 
 available through electronic publication (e.g. access to program code or data;  available through electronic publication (e.g. access to program code or data; 
 colour illustrations; animations)?  If not, have you any suggestions that  colour illustrations; animations)?  If not, have you any suggestions that 
-could be forwarded to the author? +could be forwarded to the author? **
  
 The answer to this question is clear: Definitely not. Only some color  The answer to this question is clear: Definitely not. Only some color 
Linha 143: Linha 140:
 some animation.   some animation.  
  
-___________________________________________________________________________ 
  
-Referee 3:+===== Referee 3: ===== 
  
  
geopro/pedro/mobility/revisao-jasss.1215117208.txt.gz · Última modificação: 2008/07/03 20:33 por pedro